.
Feedback

Police: Teens Beat, Rob, Man on Winfield Ave.

Harrison Police say a group of teenagers lured the victim to a secluded Harrison Street before three of the teens beat and robbed him.

Five teenagers have been arrested for their involvement in the brutal ambush and beating of a Port Chester man that took place Saturday night on Winfield Avenue in Harrison, police say.

The attackers—all but one of whom are from Harrison—lured the male victim to the secluded street by pretending to be a girl interested in a meet up, police say. While the victim waited in his vehicle at about 10:30 p.m., police say three teenage males attacked him with sawed-off lacrosse sticks and clubs and then kicked him once he was on the ground.

The victim who, according to several published reports is 21 years old, suffered severe injuries including a deep cut on his head.

Two girls who police say helped lure the victim to the scene watched the beating from a nearby parked car, police say. The group of teens stole jewelry, sneakers and $100 cash before leaving the scene, police say.

Police have arrested three males, aged 15, 16 and 19, all from Harrison, and two 15-year-old females, one from Harrison and one from Rye. Police are not releasing the names of the charged because they are eligible for youthful offender status.

After the beating, the victim was able to leave the scene in his vehicle despite severe injuries. He flagged down a responding officer in the area moments later and was rushed to White Plains Hospital. A friend of the victim's family told Patch Monday evening that the victim was still in critical condition at that time.

There was still blood on the road at the scene of the attack Sunday morning.

"This is a cold-blooded, brutal, beating and robbery," said Harrison Police Chief Anthony Marraccini.

Police believe the motive for the incident dates back several months to a series of Facebook conversation between the victim and a teenage girl. After the chats cooled off between the two, police believe the girl broke contact with the victim, but offered a Blackberry Messenger phone number, saying that the number belonged to another female interested in meeting him.

Instead, police believe the phone number belonged to one of the attackers.

Police say the attackers used ensuing conversations to lure the unwitting male to meet with them on Winfield Avenue Saturday night. Police believe one of the female suspects even answered the phone at one point, pretending to be the fictitious girl.

"It was definitely planned and pre-meditated," Marraccini said.

Police do not believe the girl from the Facebook conversations was at the scene Saturday night. She has not been charged at this point, according to police.

Each of the five suspects was charged with robbery in the first degree and gang assault in the first degree—felonies. All were arrested Sunday morning and released on $10,000 bond.

Marraccini said although this is an isolated incident, it underscores the department's need for a bigger presence in Harrison's schools. He specifically cited his on-going desire to rebuild a detective youth division that has been because of budget cuts.

Zach Oliva (Editor) February 23, 2012 at 06:49 pm
I don't know the details about his current condition, but he was in stable condition by last week. He also did not die.
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 06:49 pm
that's ridiculous, parents cannot regulate their teen's lives 24/7..they will make their own choices eventually when they are away. some kids will always choose wrong paths and make bad decisions
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 06:52 pm
that's ridiculous grass and dave.. he never touched the girl, he wasnt like forcing her to do anything..he cannot be punished for talking to her..and he was not punished..he was beaten with cut off lacrosse sticks..that's obviously morally wrong no matter what..then they robbed him, how is that punishing at all?? i know these kids btw, they do drugs but I dont think that's really relevant lol
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 06:53 pm
you idiot, he never tried to forcefully make this girl hookup with him..i know one of the girls and the guy was simply flirting, and she was flirting back. the 19 year old teen just was pissed he was flirting with one of his girls
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 06:57 pm
they do teach bullying, they can teach about bullying every single day but that wont change the fact SOME kids will still be bad and act wrong because of other factors OUTSIDE of school in their lives
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 06:59 pm
i mean sure kids drink and smoke weed but they are not violent...just a few actually do immoraly bad things to other people.
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 07:07 pm
getting into a fist fight is a "bad choice", a planned beating with cut of lacrosse sticks leaving him in critical condition is immorally wrong..no matter what the circumstances, a good kid would not beat someone..especially when he never touched the girl.
But the issue is not the schools. There will always be kids who have chosen wrong paths because of outside of school factors. you just dont hangout with those kids, and proven from this story, get involved with them..They arent just going around hallways beating kids up for no reason. Sure kids drink and some weed everywhere, that doesnt mean they do violent things. most of harrison high and other schools drink and smoke, but those are the only ones that have commited a serious violent crime.
anonymous February 23, 2012 at 07:14 pm
curfew and drinking and drugs dont have to do with this..I know kids who have no curfew, drink, and do drugs and are the nicest kids and accept everyone..Hell, I know kids who deal drugs and never have beaten someone up because they morally know better!
please stop February 23, 2012 at 11:43 pm
did i just read this right? a morally superior drug dealer? i cant read these posts anymore. this would be much more relevant if everyone would confine themselves to the limited facts as opposed to the endless conjecture. drugs, absentee parents, devils spawn, race, deep pockets, school districts, lowlife monsters, ,bullying... How does one ( right&wrong, laura, harrison student,conservative nyer) speak to bullying and good parenting while simultaneously excoriating anyone with a different opinion? isn't that the hight hypocrisy? don't we owe more dignity to a devastating situation than to callously assuage our fears with senseless demonstrations of intolerance and blame? lets please try to balance our fear and frustration with equal measures of love and compassion for everyone. i fear that this sort of recrimination is what got us here to begin with.
ConCerned February 24, 2012 at 03:41 am
as a harrison student i think you are all ignorant and I personally know some of these kids and I have never done anything, i know their parents and they are good people. They weren't, how do I put this in the soundest state of mind, which yes in its self is a bad thing but it's just a stupid teenager thing to do. I think parents should stop freaking out about these kids being in our school. If your kid is as good as you think they are (which I doubt) then they wont get involved with quote "bad kids". Calm down and stop being a nosy neighbor, especially when you know nothing.
Ktb16 February 24, 2012 at 05:00 am
After reading all the comments from this story, I must say I am flabbergasted. Instead of feeling sorry for the victim and understanding that these teenagers need help, everyone is pointing a finger at someone. It is not about whose fault it is or why these kids didn't have a curfew, it is about the action itself. I am a recent graduate from PC and seeing this occur to a fellow classmate is tragic. I just hope everyone can realize that these children need help. I understand why parents do not want these kids in the school, but that is only going to make things worse. You cannot eliminate a social environment from a teenagers life, you can limit it. Maybe this event and the recent rape case between a 17 Yr old Harrison kid and 10 yr old child will start opening every single persons eyes to the world we live it and for everyone , not just the parents, pay attention to teenagers actions.
Overlooking the town February 24, 2012 at 08:17 am
Joe Hawk don't you have a phone line to repair..
Now your making stories to have the savage beating looked to be ok saying the girl was 14 come on man
Overlooking the town February 24, 2012 at 08:44 am
Zack how come Patch isn't foiling the court for the names of everyone involved. As long as they are 17 their names can be released for Felony charges
Overlooking the town February 24, 2012 at 08:45 am
are you guys walking a tight rope because one happens to be a police sergeants son?
yes a Harrison Police Sergeants Son
Conservative NYer February 24, 2012 at 12:35 pm
ConCerned,
You age shows in your above comments and yes are you very green. Please save your comment somewhere safe perhaps in a memory box and open it up when you have children of your own (who are the same age) and then TELL US HOW YOU FEEL!! I am sure it will be the total opposite. Honestly you NOT being a parent and just a child yourself holds no water. These children brutally beat the crap out of this young man. There is NO justification for their actions.
Conservative NYer February 24, 2012 at 12:56 pm
Sorry no compassion for those idiots who did this. The VICTIM here is the young man who is in the hospital with his head trauma! Furthermore THIS WAS NOT BULLYING! This was an all OUT AGGRAVATED ASSULT! They crossed the line the second that young man was rushed to the hospital and has been in ever since. Nor was I excoriating anyone personally on this board. The direct blame is on the five J.D.'s that DID THIS and not one of them did anything to STOP IT. THAT IS WHERE THE DIRECT BLAME GOES. Like I said, was someone putting a gun to their heads telling them THEY MUST BEAT THE CRAP out of this young man and put him in the hospital not to mention the other stuff they did to him? No there wasn't. They did this on THEIR OWN ACCORD.
Dick February 24, 2012 at 03:26 pm
this is crazy stuff mannnnn!!!!!!
Right&Wrong February 24, 2012 at 06:55 pm
I don't think anyone's demonstrating senseless intolerance & blame. I applaud your call for love & compassion for everyone but differences of opinion in an open debate are part of the process of addressing this horrible incident and are not necessarily signs of indifference to others. The blatant, ignorant comments posted here are recognized by everyone as just that. Unfortunately some people just don't choose to think things through before they contribute.
And these comments are revealing details that are not part of the limited facts that have been in the press. Students at HHS are telling us in this forum that drugs/alcohol/intoxication are not only a problem in school but are also at play in this incident. In my opinion it all matters, whether you think its conjecture or not. Everyone here is troubled & concerned by what happened and we have to keep asking why it happened and how the factors that contributed to this incident can be eliminated. I'll come out and say, without blaming anyone for anything, that if parents are more aware and closely involved with their kids and everything they are doing then the probability of more incidents like this happening will be reduced if not entirely eliminated.
please stop February 24, 2012 at 07:50 pm
telling people to wake up and get a clue and calling them ignorant is intolerant and is bullying. a difference of opinion does not require name calling. telling someone that their age shows and put their feeling in a memory box is bullying and condescending. you cannot in one sentence say you have not excoriated anyone on this panel and in the next say that a comment is green and their age shows. that is bullying. that is excoriating. open debate is necessary but if you you are unable to that respectfully, than the weight of your opinions is lost and negligible. lastly, fact check please. the victim is not in the hospital and does not have brain damage. perpetuating nonsense to further an argument is inflammatory and unfortunately lends itself to total lack of credibility.
Ktb16 February 24, 2012 at 11:18 pm
Unfortunately, please stop, The victim was indeed hospitalized and was put in an induced coma until the swelling on his face decreased. He was released a few days ago. He may not have had brain injury, but he was beaten so badly that he was put in the hospital.
Conservative NYer February 25, 2012 at 03:15 pm
Not, it is giving my opinion. When I read fellow classmates of these JD’s stick up for these "good children" who are not even parents themselves their inexperience will be called out, plain and simple. How could they possibly identify with the guilt, the disappointment, the embarrassment these parents feel? THEY CAN’T AND DON'T because guess what? THEY ARE NOT PARENTS! They have NO INKLING what is means to be a parent until they are one themselves. SIMPLY AND DIRECTLY PUT: THEY ARE GREEN! And some of their comments represent their immaturity and inexperience with life which is a given of course because of their age. My comments are direct and no I don't sugar coat them either because life is not like that and nor are the comments bullying. Respectfully telling them to come back in 20 years’ time is telling them like it is because I am SURE they will feel differently especially if they are blessed to have a children one day of their own. If they can't handle a direct comment as such, then don't join in the "open debate". Again, I hope all these J.D. get their due time!!
Right&Wrong February 25, 2012 at 03:25 pm
The only intolerance I see here is you. Your screen name is Please Stop. No one but you is asking anyone in this forum to stop anything so who is intolerant here?
You entered this forum with a sarcastic comment about a post regarding a drug dealer (followed by "I can't read these posts any more") No one called you a bully or intolerant for that but God forbid we call someone ignorant for posting blatantly ignorant comments. You point on bullying is total nonsense.
francis preston February 29, 2012 at 03:29 pm
Have an emotionally vulnerable child. Moved here from NYC to get away from drugs/alchohol freely given to teens. Refuse to let my child go to the local (rye/harrison) hs bc my child says that most of the young teens are getting drunk and that 75% of the kids in school are doing drugs and the drug dealers surround the hs and the hs does nothing about it.YES THE HIGH SCHOOLS ARE RESPONSIBLE. Parents have to work in today's society, unless you are a billionaire. A child is in school functions in a context and can only function within that context. To make the child responsible and not require the high schools to have a zero tolerance for drugs, It is like saying that you can sit down to a meal with typhoid Mary and not catch it. SAFETY FIRST. A DRUG INFESTED ENVIRONMENT IS NOT A SAFE ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH TO LEARN AND THE HIGH SCHOOLS HAVE TO STOP PUTTING IT BACK ON THE KIDS AND THE PARENTS. They need drug sniffing dogs in the schools, security guards at the exits and in the halls, security cameras in the schools at all of the exits. The schools and the community must realize that IT DOES TAKE A VILLAGE.. SILENCE IS TOXIC.
Michael Fiore February 29, 2012 at 04:43 pm
The young people of today are members of a lost generation -- raised in a world where life has little to no value, the almighty dollar takes precedence and values are taught by prime time sitcoms and Saturday morning cartoons. They are being raised by television and the Internet and nourished on fast food. They are seeking comfort wherever they can find it -- in sex, drugs, music, each other. They are searching for hope and finding few answers to their questions about the meaning of life. So what is in the future? God only knows...
Lisa March 2, 2012 at 04:30 pm
I live in Silver Lake. My son goes to LMK. I love living here. My neighborhood is safe. I feel confident letting my son go out with his friends to play football in the field in town. It's not the neighborhood. It's not the schools. It's not the police department. It's the children themselves perform the actions they do. You need to have a keen eye on your children and the moment you see them faulter towards going down the wrong path, hanging out with the wrong people, you need to step in and take action. Be a PARENT to your children! Stay informed as to what they do and who they do it with.
Ross Revira March 2, 2012 at 08:04 pm
Sex, Drugs, and Rock and Roll was that not theme of the 60's ?
Anonymous you have given the most concise accurate description and antidote to the maladies described by Michael Fiore. With your common sense you should not be anonymous.
joanne March 12, 2012 at 09:55 pm
I would like to leave a comment and it is for all the right reasons... I beleive that everyone makes mistakes- We all have children who have grown up here and have been in the wrong place at the wrong time. Yet no one really knows the truth except for the people that were there. Our concern should be getting them all the help they need. It is easy to say many things about what took place but we need to look at our youth and ask what are they thinking here. This world is truly falling apart. I pray for everyone involved...
Right&Wrong March 16, 2012 at 02:43 pm
What is the antidote to the maladies mentioned by Anonymous?
Right&Wrong March 16, 2012 at 03:14 pm
You are choosing to hide from addressing actual problems in our own community by chalking this incident up to common themes many have expressed: "wrong place/wrong time", "good kids that made a mistake", "they weren't in their right minds" & "fell in with the wrong crowd". It's impossible to "fall" in with a group by the way. One chooses to hang or not hang with any group.
You are right on the mark when you say we need to look at our youth and ask what they are thinking. That's exactly where our focus needs to be at all times. And you know who is responsible for doing that? PARENTS. That is the primary duty of a functional parent and in my opinion if all parents were carrying out that duty incidents like this one would rarely, if ever, occur. We all do make mistakes in our journeys as humans. We all DO NOT have children that have been in the wrong place at the wrong time. In fact, most kids are NOT involved in incidents that warrant felony, gang assault charges (thank God). Your compassion for these kids is commendable, we should try to help anyone that is misguided. Prayers are a a great start towards that. The world isn't falling apart but we can't stop trying to make it a better place.
Right&Wrong March 16, 2012 at 05:37 pm
Well said. Couldn't agree more.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Harrison Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something